That non-expanding "+" button is almost caused by a background AJAX request failing, which breaks the page's javaScript. sometimes as you have said you hosting your website on GoDaddy hosting, this is also usually triggered by their strict Web Application Firewall (ModSecurity) which blocks the request or even by the hidden PHP warnings corrupting the data structure,
According to my experience i request you to go forward with these troubleshoots, they may help you
First.. identify the Error using Browser Console
Second, Disable MobSecurity on your cPanel
Third, Turn Off PHP Error Log
and also you can Clear the Osclass and your Browser Cache